American Journal of Mental Health Research OA
Peer-Reviewed Journal Open Access (CC BY 4.0) Bio Medical Sciences

American Journal of Mental Health Research

ISSN: 3144-8380 DOI: 10.68438 Continuous / Open Access
Research Article Open Access (CC BY 4.0)

Comparative Models of Intergenerational Trauma: The Soviet Case in Dialogue with Holocaust, Eastern European, and Postcolonial Analysis

Authors: Ahmed F. Alanazi*

DOI: 10.68438/3144-8380.1007

Publication Year: 2026

View / Download PDF

Abstract

Background: The collapse of the Soviet Union and the decades of repression, scarcity, and systemic trauma
that preceded it created conditions for the transmission of psychological distress across generations. Yet the
mechanisms and manifestations of this transmission in Soviet and post-Soviet family contexts remain fragmented
across disciplines and methodologies. The Soviet experience of the twentieth century, collectivization, the Gulag,
the Great Terror, World War II, forced deportations, and chronic material scarcity, produced forms of suffering
that were both widespread and systematically denied. Unlike the Holocaust, which generated extensive scholarly
and clinical attention to intergenerational trauma, the psychological legacies of Soviet repression have remained
comparatively underexamined.


Objective: This scoping review maps the existing literature on the intergenerational impact of mental health
among families with Soviet origins, identifying key themes, methodological approaches, and gaps in knowledge.
The review addresses a central question: What does the existing literature reveal about the intergenerational
transmission of mental health impacts in families with Soviet or post-Soviet backgrounds?


Methods: Following JBI guidance for scoping reviews, a systematic search of PubMed and supplementary sources
was conducted. Studies were included if they examined mental health outcomes across at least two generations
in families with Soviet or post-Soviet backgrounds, including emigrant populations. Data were extracted and
synthesized thematically. The search yielded 847 records, of which 19 studies met inclusion criteria.


Results: Three major themes emerged: (1) Silenced Transmission, where trauma remained present but unspoken
due to stigma and fear; (2) Embodied Vulnerability, where parental distress manifested in offspring through
psychosomatic symptoms, depression, and anxiety; and (3) Structural Continuities, where Soviet-era institutional
practices and family patterns persisted beyond regime change. These themes illuminate interconnected pathways
through which trauma was transmitted, not despite silence, but often through it; not only psychologically, but
somatically; and not merely individually, but institutionally.


Conclusions: The literature suggests that intergenerational mental health effects in Soviet families operate
through mechanisms of silence, somatic expression, and institutional perpetuation. However, the evidence
base is limited by a scarcity of multi-generational prospective studies, heavy reliance on immigrant samples,
and insufficient attention to ethnic and regional variation. A research agenda is proposed to address these
gaps, emphasizing the need for prospective longitudinal designs, research in contemporary post-Soviet states,
attention to ethnic and regional variation, and examination of the interaction between family transmission and
institutional contexts.

Keywords

Intergenerational Trauma Soviet Union Scoping Review Mental Health Family Transmission Post-Soviet